Hedges vs Fence: Which One Is Better?

May 3, 2025

When it comes to defining the boundaries of your property, two popular options come to mind: hedges and fences. While both serve the same basic purpose, they differ greatly in appearance, cost, maintenance, and long-term value. In this article, we’ll compare hedges vs fences, including the rising trend of the living hedge fence, and help you decide which one’s the better fit for your home in Florida.

At Freedom Fence, we’ve installed every type of fence available. We’ve also worked with homeowners who considered hedges. Here's what we tell our customers when they ask which one is better.

What Are the Main Differences Between a Hedge and a Fence?

A hedge is a living wall made from plants like boxwood or arborvitae. A fence is a physical barrier built from wood, vinyl, chain link, or aluminum. Some homeowners go for a living hedge fence, which blends the natural look of greenery with the structure of a boundary line.

Which Provides Better Privacy: Hedge or Fence?

Fences give you immediate privacy the moment they’re installed. Whether it’s a tall vinyl panel or a wooden barrier, you’re covered from view instantly.

Hedges or a living hedge fence take time to grow and fill in. You may wait a year or more before it gives you full privacy.

✅ Best for privacy right now: Fence

🌱 Best for natural look in the long run: Living hedge fence

Which Option Is Easier to Maintain?

Fences, especially vinyl and aluminum, require little upkeep. A simple rinse or wipe-down is enough to keep them clean.

Hedges require consistent trimming, watering, fertilizing, and pest control. A living hedge fence looks great but demands time and attention.

🧰 Low maintenance winner: Fence

✂️ Best for garden lovers: Hedge

Which Is More Cost-Effective: Hedge or Fence?

Fence installation comes with upfront labor and materials costs. At Freedom Fence, we’re transparent about pricing. Most homeowners see this as a one-time investment that lasts for years.

Hedges are cheaper to start, but long-term maintenance can outweigh the initial savings. A living hedge fence may be affordable at first but costs more over time.

💰 If you want something done fast and done right: Fence

💧 If you're ready to invest time and care: Hedge

Which Is More Durable and Long-Lasting?

Fences can last over 20 years when made from materials like vinyl or aluminum. Wood lasts slightly less but can perform well with care.

Hedges can live even longer than fences, but they are more vulnerable to disease, drought, and pests.

✅ Most durable structure: Fence

🌿 Long-lasting but high-maintenance: Hedge

Which Is More Environmentally Friendly?

A living hedge fence is the greener choice. It absorbs carbon, supports biodiversity, and reduces noise naturally.

Fences, especially synthetic ones, do not provide ecological benefits. However, sustainably sourced wood can be a better option.

🌿 Most eco-friendly: Living hedge fence

Which Is Better for Pet and Child Safety?

Fences are secure, reliable, and immediate. They’re ideal for families with dogs, young children, or pools. Freedom Fence installs code-compliant fences that meet safety regulations across Florida.

Hedges may have gaps, especially when young, and pets can dig under or run through them.

🐾 Safest choice: Fence

Which Is More Suitable for Windy Areas?

Wind can easily damage or deform thin or immature hedges. A strong fence, especially aluminum or vinyl, can handle wind well if installed with proper footing.

If you live in a windy coastal city like Sarasota or Port Charlotte, fences offer better long-term performance.

🌬️ Wind-resistant winner: Fence

How Do Hedges and Fences Affect Property Value?

A well-installed fence, especially one that complements the home’s exterior, can increase property value. Buyers often see it as a finished upgrade.

A mature, manicured hedge or living hedge fence can boost curb appeal, but if overgrown, it may turn buyers away.

🏡 Best for resale value without added work: Fence

Which Is Better for Noise Reduction?

A thick living hedge fence absorbs sound naturally. It reduces street noise and creates a quieter backyard.

Fences also block sound, though the effect depends on material and height. Solid wood or vinyl fences do offer noticeable sound reduction.

🔇 Best for noise absorption: Living hedge fence

Can You Combine Hedges and Fences for Enhanced Benefits?

Yes. Many homeowners install a fence first, then grow hedges along the inside for aesthetic and environmental benefits.

This hybrid approach gives you immediate privacy and security from the fence while adding greenery and natural insulation over time.

🛠️ Best of both worlds: Fence + Hedge combo

What Are the Pros and Cons of a Living Hedge Fence?

Pros:

Natural appearance
Eco-friendly
Great for sound absorption
Increases greenery and habitat

Cons:

Slow to mature
Requires regular care
Vulnerable to pests and drought
Less secure for kids and pets

What Are the Pros and Cons of a Fence?

Pros:

Immediate privacy and security
Low maintenance (especially vinyl and aluminum)
Long-lasting materials
Hurricane-resistant options
Pet and child safe

Cons:

Higher upfront cost
May lack the “natural” look of hedges

Looking for something long-lasting and low-maintenance?

Freedom Fence serves Sarasota, Bradenton, Venice, Port Charlotte, and nearby cities with fence solutions built to perform in Florida’s climate. Whether you're considering a vinyl privacy fence, aluminum pool barrier, or something custom, we’re ready to help.

< Older Post